Slice Of Humboldt Pie Menu
660 K St, Arcata, CA
Large orders/Office Lunches - 24hr. in advance.
When you order through our website or app and spend $100 or more, you will get free delivery from our 3rd party delivery partners (DoorDash or Uber Eats) - Up to 15 miles. Have something else in mind or questions? email: Info-orders@sliceofhumboldtpie.com
Large Party Tray of (30) Hand Pies - Reg
$150.00
Choose from all regular hand pies. Comes in a full size chaffing dish. Serves 15 - 30. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
Small Party Tray of (15) Hand Pies - Reg
$75.00
Choose from all regular hand pies. Comes in a 1/2 size chaffing dish pan. Serves 7 - 15. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
*GF Small Party Tray of (15) Hand Pies
$92.00
Choose from gluten free & reg hand pies. Comes in a 1/2 size chaffing dish. Serves 7 - 15. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
Cold-Brewed Coffee - 96oz
$25.00
96oz. of Jitter Bean Coffee. This catering caraffe will serve (12) 8oz cups of coffee or (8) 12 oz cups. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
Cold-Brewed Tea - 96oz
$25.00
96oz. of cold-brewed Smith Tea Makers (Portland, OR), black iced tea. This catering caraffe will serve (12) 8oz cups of coffee or (8) 12 oz cups. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
Tea (Hot) - 96oz
$25.00
96oz. of hot water and your choice of (12) Smith Tea Makers (Portland, OR) tea sachets. This catering caraffe will serve (12) 8oz cups of coffee or (8) 12 oz cups.
Coffee (Hot) - 96oz
$25.00
96oz. of Jitter Bean Coffee. This catering caraffe will serve (12) 8oz cups of coffee or (8) 12 oz cups
Small Party Tray of (10) - Breakfast Hand Pies
$90.00
(10) Breakfast hand pies, served in a 1/2 size chaffing dish. Choose from Veggie or Bacon. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
Large Party Tray of (20) - Breakfast Hand Pies
$180.00
(20) Breakfast hand pies, served in a full size chaffing dish. Pick from Bacon or Veggie. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
Quiche - Serves 6-8
$0.00
Choose from veggie or or bacon quiche. May be ordered in gluten free as well. *Click for more details/options. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
Party Size Salads
$0.00
Serves 6 - 20 - *Click for more details/options. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
*GF Large Party Tray of (30) Hand Pies
$185.00
Choose from gluten free & reg hand pies. Comes in a full size chaffing dish. Serves 15 - 30. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
Sweet Pies - Serves 6 - 8
$0.00
Choose from any of our on menu pies, regular or gluten free. *Click for more details/options. (Requires an 24hrs advanced order).
Thanksgiving Pies - Pick up only
Start your order by choosing a date, then select your holiday pie pickup (Nov 21–26) within the order. Your confirmation shows the start date, but your chosen pickup is official. Please order holiday pies separately from regular orders. Don’t wait—pickup times fill fast! We can’t wait to bake holiday magic for you!
9" The Leftover - Family (T)
$38.00
Only available to order for Tues, Nov 25th & Wed, Nov 26th, during the week of Thanksgiving. *Serves 4–6 Left Over Pot Pies will be served COLD/UNBAKED. Orders stop at the end of the day Wed, Nov 19th - OR SOONER.
9" Pumpkin - Whole (T)
$32.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
9" Sour Cherry - Whole (T)
$34.00
Whole pitted sour cherries, that are lightly sweetened. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
9" Chocolate Silk - Whole (T)
$35.00
Light silky chocolate mousse, mounded with fluffy whipped cream and shaved chocolate. (Contains raw eggs)
9" Black Bottom Pecan - Whole (T)
$36.00
Our pecan pie with a layer of dark chocolate ganache.
9" Lemon Raspberry - Whole (T)
$30.00
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote and topped with dollops of whipped cream.
9" Pecan - Whole (T)
$34.00
Chopped pecans in a sweet gooey filling, baked in a flaky pie crust.
9" Apple Cider Cream - Whole (T)
$34.00
Apple pie meets cream pie, tart, tangy, sweet, and creamy.
9" Traditional Apple - Whole (T)
$28.00
Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
9" Blackberry - Whole (T)
$32.00
Blackberries lightly sweetened to let the berries tartness shine through. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
**Pie Crusts/Dough - Traditional (T)
$4.00
9" Pumpkin Walnut - Whole (T)
$35.00
Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.
*9" GF Pumpkin - Whole (T)
$36.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
*9" GF Blackberry - Whole (T)
$38.00
Blackberries lightly sweetened to let the berries tartness shine through. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
9" Vegan Pumpkin - Whole (T)
$34.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
9” Chicken Pot Pie – Served Frozen (T)
$30.00
Chicken breast, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce. Served Frozen
9” Sun-Dried Tomato Quiche - Served Cold (T)
$30.00
Sun-Dried tomatoes, spinach and Cypress Grove Goat Cheese
*9" GF/Vegan Pumpkin Walnut - Whole (T)
$44.00
Our vegan pumpkin pie topped with a vegan and gluten free walnut streusel topping.
*9" GF Black Bottom Pecan - Whole (T)
$40.00
Our gluten free pecan pie with a layer of dark chocolate ganache.
**5" The Leftover - Individual (T)
$9.75
A layer of mashed potatoes, shredded turkey, turkey gravy, topped with a hefty amount of flavorful stuffing and served with a side of Cranberry Sauce OR Turkey Gravy. Left Over Pot Pies will be served COLD/UNBAKED.
*9” GF Sun-Dried Tomato Quiche - Served Cold (T)
$34.00
Sun-Dried tomatoes, spinach and Cypress Grove Goat Cheese
*9" GF Traditional Apple - Whole (T)
$34.00
Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
*9" GF Lemon Raspberry - Whole (T)
$34.00
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote and topped with dollops of whipped cream.
9” Bacon Quiche – Served Cold (T)
$30.00
Potatoes, carrots, peas, green beans, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce. Served Frozen
5" (V) - Pumpkin Coconut Curry Pot Pie (T) - Served Frozen
$8.00
A Pumpkin, Coconut curry, with sauteed spinach, red bell peppers and chick peas. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly. Served Frozen
*9" GF Sour Cherry - Whole (T)
$40.00
Whole pitted sour cherries, that are lightly sweetened. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
*9" GF Chocolate Silk - Whole (T)
$39.00
Light silky chocolate mousse, mounded with fluffy whipped cream and shaved chocolate. (Contains raw eggs)
* 9"GF/V Pumpkin - Whole (T)
$38.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
*9" GF Pecan - Whole (T)
$38.00
Chopped pecans in a sweet gooey filling, baked in a gluten free pie crust.
*9" GF Apple Cider Cream - Whole (T)
$38.00
Apple pie meets cream pie, tart, tangy, sweet, and creamy.
9" Vegan Pumpkin Walnut - Whole (T)
$37.00
Our vegan pumpkin pie topped with a vegan walnut streusel topping.
*9” GF Chicken Pot Pie – Served Frozen (T)
$36.00
Chicken breast, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce. Served Frozen
*9” GF Bacon Quiche – Served Cold (T)
$34.00
Applewood smoked bacon, swiss cheese and caramelized onions.
9" Peanut Butter Fudge - Whole (T)
$31.00
This pie has a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge, and topped with a light fluffy peanut butter cream, and then frozen.
**Pie Crusts/Dough - Gluten Free (T)
$6.00
Our gluten free crust is vegan. Choose between a ball of dough w/ a tin, a crimped crust or top & bottom flat crust, w/ a pie tin.
9” Veggie Pot Pie – Served Frozen (T)
$30.00
Potatoes, carrots, peas, green beans, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce. Served Frozen
9" Buttermilk - Whole (T)
$30.00
This is a creamy centered pie, with just the right amount of sweetness.
**Side of Fresh Whipped Cream (T)
$8.00
*9” GF Veggie Pot Pie – Served Frozen (T)
$36.00
Potatoes, carrots, peas, green beans, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce. Served Frozen
*9" GF Pumpkin Walnut - Whole (T)
$41.00
Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery gluten free walnut streusel topping.
*9" GF Buttermilk - Whole (T)
$34.00
This is a creamy centered pie, with just the right amount of sweetness.
*9" GF Peanut Butter Fudge - Whole (T)
$35.00
This pie is lined with fudge, and topped with a light fluffy peanut butter cream, and then frozen, in a traditional gluten free crust.
Christmas Pies - Pick up only
Our system allows orders up to 7 days in advance. Choose a date within the next 7 days to start the ordering process. When ordering Holiday Pies, select your pickup time and day from 12/19 - 12/24 This is the date we will schedule for your pickup. After choosing the start date, you'll receive a confirmation email. Pickup days fill up quickly, so don’t wait!
9" Chocolate Peppermint - Whole (C)
$32.00
Chocolate brownie-like pie with a hint of peppermint, finished with a ring of whipped cream and dusted with candy cane bits.
9" Blackberry - Whole (C)
$32.00
Blackberries lightly sweetened to let the berries tartness shine through. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
9" Vegan Pumpkin Walnut - Whole (C)
$37.00
Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.
*9" GF Chocolate Peppermint - Whole (C)
$36.00
Chocolate brownie-like pie with a hint of peppermint, finished with a ring of whipped cream and dusted with candy cane bits.
9" Spiked Eggnog - Whole (C)
$34.00
Our pie version of the classic boozy holiday drink! A creamy rum spiked custard finished with whipped cream and sprinkled with nutmeg, featuring Humboldt Distillery Organic Rum.
9" Gingerbread Cream - Whole (C)
$34.00
This pie has the warm spiced flavor of gingerbread, topped with whipped cream.
9" Pecan - Whole (C)
$34.00
Chopped pecans in a sweet gooey filling, baked in a flaky pie crust.
Pie Crusts/Dough - Regular (C)
$4.00
Our crusts are vegan. Choose between a ball of dough w/ a tin, a crimped crust or top & bottom flat crust, w/ a pie tin.
Pie Crusts/Dough - Gluten Free (C)
$6.00
Our gluten free crust is vegan. Choose between a ball of dough w/ a tin, a crimped crust or top & bottom flat crust, w/ a pie tin.
Side of Fresh Whipped Cream (C)
$8.00
*9” GF Chicken Pot Pie – Served Frozen (C)
$36.00
Chicken breast, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce.
9” Chicken Pot Pie – Served Frozen (C)
$30.00
Chicken breast, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce. Served Frozen
*9” GF Veggie Pot Pie – Served Frozen (C)
$36.00
Potatoes, carrots, peas, green beans, onions and celery in a creamy sauce. Served Frozen
9” Veggie Pot Pie – Served Frozen (C)
$30.00
Potatoes, carrots, peas, green beans, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce. Served Frozen.
5" (V) Pumpkin Coconut Curry Pot Pie (C) - Served Frozen
$8.00
A pumpkin, coconut curry, with sauteed spinach, red bell peppers and chick peas. Without an eggwash to keep it vegan friendly. Served Frozen
*9" GF Sun-Dried Tomato Quiche - Whole (C)
$34.00
Sun-Dried tomatoes, spinach and Cypress Grove Goat Cheese.
9" Sun-Dried Tomato Quiche - Whole (C)
$30.00
Sun-Dried tomatoes, spinach and Cypress Grove Goat Cheese.
*9" GF Bacon Quiche - Whole (C)
$34.00
Applewood smoked bacon, swiss cheese and caramelized onions.
9" Bacon Quiche - Whole (C)
$30.00
Applewood smoked bacon, swiss cheese and caramelized onions.
*9" GF Spiked Eggnog - Whole (C)
$38.00
Our pie version of the classic boozy holiday drink! A creamy rum spiked custard finished with whipped cream and sprinkled with nutmeg, featuring Humboldt Distillery Organic Rum.
*9" GF Gingerbread Cream - Whole (C)
$38.00
This pie has the warm spiced flavor of gingerbread, topped with whipped cream.
*9" GF Blackberry - Whole (C)
$38.00
Blackberries lightly sweetened to let the berries tartness shine through. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
*9" GF Chocolate Silk - Whole (C)
$39.00
Light silky chocolate mousse, mounded with fluffy whipped cream and shaved chocolate. (Contains raw eggs)
9" Chocolate Silk - Whole (C)
$35.00
Light silky chocolate mousse, mounded with fluffy whipped cream and shaved chocolate. (Contains raw eggs.)
*9" GF Peanut Butter Fudge - Whole (C)
$35.00
This pie is lined with fudge, and topped with a light fluffy peanut butter cream, and then frozen. We will use our traditional gluten free crust for gluten free orders.
9" Peanut Butter Fudge - Whole (C)
$31.00
This pie has a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge, and topped with a light fluffy peanut butter cream, and then frozen.
*9" GF Traditional Apple - Whole (C)
$34.00
Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Without eggwash to be vegan friendly.
9" Traditional Apple - Whole (C)
$28.00
Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. With out an eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
*9" GF Lemon Raspberry - Whole (C)
$34.00
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote and topped with dollops of whipped cream.
9" Lemon Raspberry - Whole (C)
$30.00
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote and topped with dollops of whipped cream.
9" Vegan Pumpkin - Whole (C)
$34.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
*9" GF Pumpkin - Whole (C)
$36.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
*9" GF/V Pumpkin - Whole (C)
$38.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
9" Pumpkin - Whole (C)
$32.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
*9" GF Pumpkin Walnut - Whole (C)
$41.00
Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.
*9" GF/V Pumpkin Walnut - Whole (C)
$43.00
Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.
9" Pumpkin Walnut - Whole (C)
$35.00
Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.
*9" GF Pecan - Whole (C)
$38.00
Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.
*9" GF Black Bottom Pecan - Whole (C)
$40.00
Our pecan pie with a layer of dark chocolate ganache.
9" Black Bottom Pecan - Whole (C)
$36.00
Our pecan pie with a layer of dark chocolate ganache.
*9" GF Sour Cherry - Whole (C)
$40.00
Whole pitted sour cherries, that are lightly sweetened. Without an eggwash to be vegan friendly.
9" Sour Cherry - Whole (C)
$34.00
Whole pitted sour cherries, that are lightly sweetened. Without an eggwash to be vegan friendly.
Quiche
Limited quantity per day. Most whole quiches must be ordered 24 hrs. in advance.
Sun-Dried Tomato Quiche - Slice
$6.00
Sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, and Cypress Grove goat cheese (Arcata). *If you choose to add a side salad, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice".
9" Sun Dried Tomato Quiche - Must be ordered 24hrs. in advance.
$30.00
Sun Dried tomatoes, spinach, Cypress Grove goat cheese. A whole quiche – must be ordered 24hrs. in advance.
Bacon Quiche-Slice
$6.00
Applewood bacon, swiss cheese and carmelized onions. *If you choose to add a side salad, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice".
Small Hand Pies
Spinach & Ricotta (available through 11/29)
$5.00
Sauteed fresh baby spinach, onions and garlic, blended with creamy ricotta and parmesan.
Sweet Potato & Black Bean (available through 11/29)
$5.00
Sweet potatoes, black beans, fresh cilantro and green onions, seasoned with warm spices.
GF/V Sweet Potato & Black Bean Hand Pie (available through 11/29)
$5.50
Sweet potatoes, black beans, fresh cilantro and green onions, seasoned with warm spices.
Pot Pies - 5" individual & 9" Family Size
Individual 5" or Family 9". A family 9" pot pie is available (Chicken & Veggie) Hot - ready in 1 hr. for here or togo. Or served frozen for a take and bake.
Chicken Pot Pie - 9"
$30.00
Roasted chicken, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion and celery in a creamy sauce. Hot - ready in 1 hr. for here or togo. Or served frozen for a take and bake.
*GF Chicken Pot Pie - 5"
$10.00
Gluten-Free. Chicken breast, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion and celery in a creamy sauce. *If a side salad is chosen, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice"
Veggie Pot Pie - 5"
$8.00
Green beans, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy veggie gravy. *If a side salad is chosen, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice"
*GF Chicken Pot Pie - 9"
$36.00
Gluten-Free. Chicken breast, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion and celery in a creamy sauce. Hot - ready in 1 hr. for here or togo. Or served frozen for a take and bake.
Veggie Pot Pie - 9"
$30.00
Green beans, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy veggie gravy. Hot- ready in 1 hr. for here or togo. Or served frozen for a take and bake.
*GF Veggie Pot Pie - 9"
$36.00
Green beans, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy veggie gravy. Hot- ready in 1 hr. for here or togo. Or served frozen for a take and bake.
Sweet Pie - Slices
Don't forget to add a scoop of ice cream or a bit of whipped cream to your slice!
Lemon Raspberry Pie - Slice
$6.00
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote, topped with a ring of whipped cream.
Chocolate Silk Pie - Slice
$6.50
Light silky dark chocolate mousse, mounded with whipped cream. Contains raw eggs.
Pecan - Slice - Slice (avail. through 11/29)
$6.50
Chopped pecans in a sweet gooey filling, baked in a flaky pie crust.
Pumpkin Walnut (available through 11/29)
$6.50
Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.
Apple Pie - Slice
$6.00
Thinly sliced apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg.
Black Bottom Pecan - Slice (available through 11/29)
$6.50
Our pecan pie with a bottom layer of chocolate ganache.
Apple Cider Cream - Slice (available through 11/29)
$6.50
Apple pie meets cream pie, tart, tangy, sweet, creamy and finished with a ring of whipped cream.
Peanut Butter Fudge - Slice
$6.00
This frozen pie is in a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge, and topped with a light and fluffy peanut butter cream
*GF Lemon Raspberry Pie - Slice
$6.50
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote, topped with a ring of whipped cream, in a gluten free crust.
Buttermilk - Slice (available through 11/29)
$6.00
This is a creamy centered pie, with just the right amount of sweetness.
GF Pumpkin - Slice (avail. through 11/29)
$7.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices, in a gluten free crust.
Pumpkin Pie -Slice - Slice (Available until 11/29)
$6.50
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
GF/V Apple Pie - Slice (available through 11/29)
$6.50
Thinly sliced, crisp granny smith apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Without egg wash to keep it vegan friendly.
Sweet Pies - 9" Whole
Get your pie whole or by the slice! Our gluten free crust is made in-house using organic gluten free flours. "If your favorite flavor isn’t listed, visit us or call to submit an "Off-Menu Request". Upon approval, a $5 off-menu fee and the cost of the pie apply. Your custom flavor will be ready within 48 hours!"
Lemon Raspberry Pie - Whole
$30.00
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote, topped with a ring of whipped cream.
Peanut Butter Fudge Pie - Whole
$31.00
This frozen pie is in a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge, and topped with a light and fluffy peanut butter cream
Chocolate Silk Pie - Whole
$35.00
Light silky dark chocolate mousse, mounded with whipped cream.
*GF Lemon Raspberry Pie - Whole
$34.00
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote, topped with a ring of whipped cream.
Traditional Apple - Whole
$28.00
Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. With out an egg wash to keep this pie vegan friendly. Gluten free may be ordered 24hrs. in advance.
Pecan - Whole (available through 11/29)
$34.00
Chopped pecans in a sweet gooey filling, baked in a flaky pie crust. Gluten free may be ordered 24hrs. in advance.
Black Bottom Pecan - Whole (available through 11/29)
$36.00
Our pecan pie with a bottom layer of chocolate ganache. Gluten Free may be ordered 24hrs in advance.
Apple Cider Cream Pie - Whole (Available through 11/29)
$34.00
Apple pie meets cream pie, tart, tangy, sweet, and creamy. Gluten free may be ordered 24 hours in advance.
Pumpkin Walnut - Whole (Available through 11/29)
$35.00
Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping. Gluten Free may be ordered 24hrs. in advance-*GF contains soy.
Buttermilk - Whole (Available through 11/29)
$30.00
This is a creamy centered pie, with just the right amount of sweetness. Just try it! Gluten Free may be ordered 24hrs. in advance.
GF Pumpkin - Whole (available through 11/29)
$36.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices, in a gluten free crust.
Pumpkin Pie - Whole (Available through 11/29)
$32.00
Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.
