Best American restaurant in Arcata

Satisfy Your Cravings with Our Delicious Pie Offerings!

Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Sun Dried Tomato Quiche Slice

Sun dried tomatoes, spinach, and Cypress Grove goat cheese (Arcata). *If you choose to add a side salad, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice".

Add Item

Ham & Swiss Quiche Slice

Ham & Swiss cheese quiche. *If you choose to add a side salad, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice".

Add Item

GF Sun Dried Tomato Quiche Slice

Sun dried tomatoes, spinach, and Cypress Grove goat cheese, in our gluten free crust. *If you choose to add a side salad, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice".

Add Item

Corn & Cheese Hand Pie

Sauteed corn, mild peppers, and jack cheese. Simple and flavorful!

Add Item

Pulled Pork & Green Chili

Smoky, tender pulled pork simmered with roasted chili peppers and spices. *If a side salad is chosen, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice"

Add Item

Chicken Pot Pie - 9" Family Size

Roasted chicken, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion and celery in a creamy sauce. Hot - ready in 1 hr. for here or togo. Or served frozen for a take and bake.

Add Item

*GF Chicken Pot Pie - 5" Individual

Gluten-Free. Chicken breast, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion and celery in a creamy sauce. *If a side salad is chosen, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice"

Add Item

Peanut Butter Chess - Slice

Rich peanut buttery goodness topped with a chocolate ganache and sprinkled with chopped peanuts

Add Item

Peanut Butter Chess - Whole

Rich peanut buttery goodness topped with a chocolate ganache and sprinkled with chopped peanuts

Add Item

Veggie Pot Pie

Potatoes, carrots, peas, green beans, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce

Add Item

📌Welcome to Slice Of Humboldt Pie🥧

At Slice Of Humboldt Pie, we’re all about delicious pies and good vibes! Located in Arcata, CA, our cozy pie shop is where you can find sweet and savory pies made with love. We have something for everyone, whether you’re craving a hearty pot pie, a tasty hand pie, or a scrumptious sweet pie. Plus, we offer fresh salads if you’re looking for something light. Meat lovers, vegetarians, gluten-free eaters, and vegans can all enjoy our menu!

Fresh and Made with Care ෆ

We take pride in what we serve. Everything is made from scratch right in our kitchen. We roast full chickens every day for our chicken pot pies and peel every apple for our sweet pies. This means you get fresh, tasty food every time you visit. We’re dedicated to bringing the best flavors to Humboldt County, and we can’t wait for you to try them!

Easy Ordering for Everyone

Life gets busy, and we totally get that! That’s why ordering from us is super easy. You can choose to dine in with us, or if you’re on the go, we’ve got delivery and takeout ready for you. Planning a party? Our catering service is perfect for bulk orders, making sure your guests enjoy a memorable meal. We’re here to make your life easier and your meals delicious!

Come Visit Us

So why wait? Whether you’re a local looking for a casual place to eat or a visitor wanting to try something new, Slice Of Humboldt Pie is here for you. Swing by or order online today! Let’s make your day a little sweeter (or savvier) with our yummy pies. We look forward to serving you soon!🥧✨

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Now

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

DELICIOUS! They were suggested to us from a friend who lives in the area on a place to go for GF options. We had the GF sweet pies. We tried the chocolate, lemon raspberry & blueberry- names might not be totally accurate - they were AMAZING! We were also able to have our dog on a leash out on the porch with us while we ate. We will definitely go back again when in the area. We would like to try the Savory pies. Thank you for offering GF options!!!

Kemmerr P.

Such a gem. This spot has the best selection of pie, dessert and savory, I’ve ever seen. We got the French silk and peanut butter fudge, both EPIC and really perfect portions. Guys behind counter was awesome and service was fast. Hope we get to come back!

Teri B.

Have always been a big fan of Slice and now to see their new space, it completes the idea of what I always wanted a visit to them to be like. Great space, open and welcoming. As ever, the best pies, sweet and savory, in Humboldt.